Who Are You Without the Shoulds?

There is a strange moment that can happen after you’ve done everything you thought you were supposed to do.

You worked hard. You built the career. You became dependable. You became the person who could figure things out, push through, get things done, and keep going. And then one day you look around at the life you’ve built and think:

This should be enough.

So why does something still feel like it’s missing?

That question sits at the heart of my conversation with Jim Hughes, founder of Become Untamed.

Because Jim isn’t interested in helping people become someone new. He’s interested in helping them recognize who they were before years of expectations, fear, achievement, responsibility, and all those shoulds began telling them who they needed to be.

And he introduced me to a way of thinking about our patterns that I haven’t stopped thinking about since.

What if there isn’t just one version of you standing on the stage?

What if you have an entire cast?

▶ Watch the Conversation

Who Are You Without the Shoulds? | Jim Hughes

Listen Everywhere

Prefer to listen?

This conversation is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube, and everywhere podcasts are available.

In This Conversation

Jim and I explore:

• Why a life that looks successful from the outside can still feel misaligned on the inside.
• What happens when our identity becomes wrapped around being the person who always gets things done.
• How years of expectations can quietly turn into the things we believe we should want.
• Why fear doesn’t have to disappear before we move forward.
• How achievement and overworking can become ways of avoiding something deeper.
• Why energy can offer clues about where we feel most aligned.
• How our greatest gifts can sometimes sit surprisingly close to our greatest pain.
• Why clarity often comes from action rather than waiting until we’re completely certain.
• How overeating, overworking, people-pleasing, avoidance, and other unhealthy habits and patterns may be symptoms rather than the actual problem.
• Why removing a behavior without understanding what it was doing for us may simply give the underlying need somewhere else to go.
• How to begin reconnecting with yourself when you aren’t even sure who you are anymore.

But the idea that stayed with me most was Jim’s Cast List.

The Cast List

Imagine your mind as a stage. Waiting behind the curtain are different versions of you. The achiever. The protector. The people-pleaser. The perfectionist. The fearful child. Each learned something about how to survive, belong, succeed, stay safe, or be loved. And depending on what life puts in front of us, one of those characters may walk onto the stage and take the microphone.

That’s where this became especially interesting to me. Because we tend to look at an unhealthy behavior and ask:

Why am I doing this again?

But Jim takes us further back. Before the behavior, there may be an emotion. Before the emotion, there may be a story. And behind that story may be a member of our cast who learned a very long time ago that this was how we stayed safe. Suddenly the question changes.

Not: What’s wrong with me?

But: Who has the microphone right now?

One Moment That Stayed With Me

Jim said something about these older versions of ourselves that completely changed the way I heard his framework.

He doesn’t ask us to get rid of them. He doesn’t ask us to fight them. And he certainly doesn’t ask us to hate them. We can understand why they showed up. We can thank them for what they were trying to do. And when they no longer need to be running the show, we can gently invite them to step away from center stage.

That landed deeply for me. Because so much personal growth language is about eliminating something. Stop doing this. Fix that. Get rid of the bad habit. Become more disciplined. But what if understanding the pattern comes before changing it?

Maybe we don’t need to fight every old version of ourselves. Maybe we need to understand why they learned to fight for us.

About Jim Hughes

Jim Hughes is the founder of Become Untamed, an international speaker, business and personal coach, and former engineering leader who helps people reconnect with who they are beneath expectations, fear, and the stories they’ve accumulated along the way.

His own journey began with questions many successful people eventually find themselves asking: Who am I? What do I actually want? Who do I want to serve? What kind of life do I want to lead?

Today, Jim works with entrepreneurs, executives, senior military leaders, Olympic athletes, and business owners, helping people recognize the patterns and stories influencing their choices and create greater alignment, energy, fulfillment, and purpose in their lives.

His Cast List framework helps people identify the different versions of themselves that can step forward in response to fear, expectations, relationships, and old experiences.

Guest Quote

“Clarity comes from action, not the other way around.”
— Jim Hughes

I loved this because so many of us believe we need certainty before we’re allowed to move. Jim offers another possibility. Take an intentional step. Pay attention. Learn. Then take another.

Discover Your Cast List

Jim has created a FREE Cast List Assessment to help you begin exploring the different characters that may be showing up in your own life.

Take the Free Cast List Assessment

Connect with Jim Hughes

Become Untamed
Visit Become Untamed

LinkedIn
Connect with Jim Hughes

🎙 Behind the Mic

After every conversation, I spend a few minutes sharing what stayed with me after the microphones were turned off.

With Jim, I kept coming back to his stage.

Because before we change a behavior, before we interrupt an unhealthy pattern, before we choose something healthier, we may need to recognize who inside of us is making the choice.

Sometimes it isn’t today’s version of us at all. Sometimes it’s a much younger version who is still trying to keep us safe. So my question after this conversation became:

Instead of asking “What’s wrong with me?” what would happen if we asked, “Which part of me is speaking right now?”

Maybe the answer would come with far more compassion than criticism.

▶ Watch Behind the Mic: Which Part of You Is Making the Choice?

Continue the Journey

Every Tuesday I share a true story from my life as PJ Hamilton.

Every Wednesday I step Behind the Mic to unpack what these conversations are teaching me.

Every Thursday a new Delay the Binge™ episode goes live.

Together, they’re designed to help you pause long enough to notice the patterns quietly shaping your life, understand what they may be costing you, and discover the small choices that help you keep becoming.

A Personal Note from Pam

For a long time, I thought growth meant eventually getting rid of the parts of myself I didn’t like.

The people-pleaser. The overworker. The part of me that could walk into a room, immediately figure out what everyone else needed, and start becoming it.

I thought becoming healthier meant those versions of me would eventually disappear.

Jim’s Cast List gave me another way to look at them.

Those parts of me didn’t appear because something was wrong with me. They learned their roles somewhere along the way. They were trying to accomplish something. Keep me safe. Help me belong. Avoid conflict. Earn approval. Keep everything moving.

I don’t have to hand them the microphone forever. But I also don’t have to hate them. We’re not trying to become someone else. We’re becoming more of who we’ve always been, with a better understanding of the patterns we’ve carried with us. And maybe that’s where the pause begins.

Who has the microphone right now?

Pause. Choose. Build momentum. Finish stronger.

Pam